- Strategy holds 714,644 BTC, owes about $6 billion, and says it can still cover its debt even if bitcoin drops to $8,000
- Critics warn a deep price fall could mean large paper losses, difficult refinancing, and possible shareholder dilution through new equity sales
Bitcoin sharp slide from record levels is testing the balance sheet strategy of one of its largest corporate holders. Software and treasury firm Strategy (MSTR), led by Michael Saylor, told investors it can endure a plunge in bitcoin’s price to $8,000 and still meet all of its debt obligations. The company has used the cryptocurrency as its primary treasury reserve since 2020 and has financed a large portion of its holdings with debt, drawing both support and criticism as market conditions have shifted.
Strategy outlines ability to withstand deep Bitcoin drawdown
In a Sunday post on X, Strategy said it could tolerate a drop in the price of bitcoin to $8,000 and still possess enough assets to cover its liabilities in full. The company stated that at that level, the value of its bitcoin would still equal $6 billion, matching its current debt load. The firm emphasized that it does not face a single lump-sum repayment, as its debt maturities are staggered between 2027 and 2032, which it argues gives it room to manage obligations over time.
Strategy has accumulated 714,644 BTC since adopting bitcoin as a treasury asset four years ago, a stash it says is larger than that of any other public company. At current market prices, those holdings are worth about $49.3 billion. The company has financed much of this position with borrowings, owing roughly $6 billion, or the equivalent of 86,956 BTC, against bitcoin reserves more than eight times that size. This approach has been mirrored by other firms, including Tokyo-listed Metaplanet (3350), which has also embraced debt-funded bitcoin purchases.
The practice was celebrated by many investors during the digital asset’s bull run, particularly as bitcoin surged to more than $126,000 in October. However, the subsequent decline to near $60,000 has raised concerns about the sustainability of heavy leverage tied to a volatile asset. Observers warn that if Strategy were forced to sell a significant portion of its bitcoin to meet its debts, the resulting liquidation could overwhelm market demand and accelerate price declines.
Debt strategy, convertible securities, and plans to shift into equity
To address questions around its capital structure, Strategy has signaled that it intends to convert some of its existing debt into equity. The company said it aims to “equitize” current convertible obligations rather than issue additional senior debt, which would rank above existing creditors. Convertible debt allows lenders to exchange what they are owed for MSTR shares once the stock price reaches a set threshold, creating a path to reduce cash repayments if equity markets are strong.
Under more favorable market conditions, this structure has worked to Strategy’s advantage. When the company’s stock traded above $400, bondholders could convert their notes into shares. In that scenario, hedge funds and other investors who had purchased the bonds often closed their short positions in the stock as part of their strategies, and the company avoided large cash outflows because the debt effectively disappeared through conversion.
Strategy’s use of convertible bonds has attracted specific types of investors. Anton Golub, chief business officer at crypto exchange Freedx, said that buyers of these instruments have largely been Wall Street hedge funds that focus on volatility arbitrage rather than on bitcoin itself. Their strategy typically involves acquiring convertible bonds at what they view as attractive prices while simultaneously shorting the underlying equity. This combination allows them to profit from differences between the implied volatility embedded in the options within the bond and the realized volatility of the shares, while still collecting interest and benefiting from discounted bonds drifting up toward par value by maturity.
Critics question resilience if bitcoin falls to $8,000
Despite Strategy’s assurances, several market participants remain unconvinced that the company could easily navigate a severe downturn in bitcoin. A pseudonymous macro asset manager using the name Capitalists Exploits argued that although a price of $8,000 might technically leave enough asset value to cover the firm’s $6 billion in net debt, the broader financial picture would be far more troubling. The critic said Strategy is estimated to have spent around $54 billion building its bitcoin reserve, implying an average acquisition cost of about $76,000 per coin. A fall to $8,000 would therefore represent a paper loss of around $48 billion, a hit that could significantly damage how lenders and investors view the company’s balance sheet.
The same observer noted that Strategy’s cash resources would only support about 2.5 years of debt servicing and dividend distributions at present levels. Meanwhile, the firm’s core software operation generates approximately $500 million in annual revenue, which the critic described as insufficient relative to the scale of its obligations. According to this assessment, the company faces $8.2 billion of convertible bonds and an additional $8 billion in preferred shares. The preferred instruments come with sizable, ongoing dividend requirements that function similarly to high interest costs, compounding the strain.
From this perspective, refinancing could become difficult if bitcoin were to tumble toward $8,000. Capitalists Exploits argued that conventional lenders would be hesitant to extend new credit to a business whose main asset had undergone substantial depreciation, especially if the conversion features in its securities had become economically meaningless and key credit indicators had worsened. The observer suggested that new borrowing, if available at all, might require yields in the 15%–20% range to appeal to investors, or might fail outright in a stressed market.
Bitcoin volatility, hedge fund arbitrage, and fears of shareholder dilution
Golub, from Freedx, was particularly critical of Strategy’s plan to push more of its debt into equity. He described the move as a deliberate effort to shift risk onto retail shareholders. In his view, the convertible bonds were initially structured and priced under the assumption of relatively modest price fluctuations in MSTR shares. Instead, the stock experienced pronounced swings, providing fertile ground for hedge funds that had bought the convertibles and sold the stock short to capture gains from volatility, interest income, and the gradual re-pricing of discounted bonds.
When MSTR traded above $400, this arbitrage structure reached an optimal outcome for both the hedge funds and the company: funds converted bonds into equity, closed their short positions, and Strategy avoided significant cash redemptions. Now, with the stock around $130, the conversion option is deeply out of the money, and bondholders have little incentive to swap their debt for shares. Golub expects that, under these conditions, hedge funds will prefer to receive full cash repayment once the notes mature, raising the risk of pressure on Strategy’s liquidity.
Golub anticipates that the firm will respond by issuing new equity to meet these obligations. In his assessment, Strategy is likely to raise capital through at-the-market (ATM) share sales, a mechanism that allows companies to sell stock incrementally into the open market. He contends that this approach would effectively dilute existing shareholders to generate the funds needed to repay hedge funds holding the convertible bonds. Golub argued that Strategy’s model appears highly effective during periods when bitcoin prices rise sharply, but becomes damaging to MSTR shareholders when the market turns downward, as equity dilution erodes their stakes.
Conclusion
Strategy’s bitcoin-centered balance sheet is back under the spotlight as the cryptocurrency trades far below its recent highs. The company insists that its 714,644 BTC, combined with a spread-out maturity profile and plans to shift debt into equity, provide sufficient protection even if prices collapse to $8,000. Skeptics counter that the scale of potential paper losses, the burden of outstanding convertible bonds and preferred shares, and the limited cash and operating income could complicate refinancing and increase reliance on shareholder dilution. As bitcoin’s volatility persists, Strategy’s approach faces a pivotal test from both credit markets and equity investors.
Disclaimer
The information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. The article does not offer sufficient information to make investment decisions, nor does it constitute an offer, recommendation, or solicitation to buy or sell any financial instrument. The content is opinion of the author and does not reflect any view or suggestion or any kind of advise from CryptoNewsBytes.com. The author declares he does not hold any of the above mentioned tokens or received any incentive from any company.
Featured image created by AI
